Thanks Amtrak, for fast thinking and quick action

by Ned Levi on February 8, 2010

Amtrak's 30th Street Station, Philadelphia - Photo by Lisa Cee, http://www.flickr.com/photos/39539890@N02/

It’s been said, “There are two sayings that are familiar in every news room across the country: ‘sex sells’ and ‘if it bleeds it leads.’” Bad news and controversy definitely peak readers’ interest.

Sorry, I have no sex or blood in my column today. I’m going to tell an Amtrak story, which occurred this past Saturday, when I traveled from Philadelphia to New York City, in the midst of the big snowstorm. Amtrak employees saved our day.My wife, younger adult son and I enjoy opera. Don’t snicker. Great opera is great theater, and at the Metropolitan Opera, its quality, and that of its performers is second to none, the world over.

We chose our current season subscription, specifically for Saturday’s opera, Simon Boccanegra, mostly because Plácido Domingo was set to perform the lead role, in this opera, for his first time. In our opinion, he is the world’s greatest living active male opera star. His voice is amazing, and his acting wonderful.

As Saturday approached, with its forecast of an impending “blizzard of the century,” you can imagine our consternation. Were we going to miss this major event, this very special performance? Any time you have the opportunity to see a star of this magnitude perform, it’s a special occasion.

Saturday morning came with a foot of snow on the ground, and 3 foot drifts, and while Philadelphia International was essentially closed, Amtrak was running close to normal, from Philadelphia, north. We had tickets on the “Keystoner.”

We walked through the snow and 30 mph winds to Amtrak’s 30th Street Station, Philadelphia. I went to print the tickets, purchased on the Internet, at one of the kiosks. I usually have no problems with them, but on Saturday, none of them worked. I tried several before I gave up. With the bad weather outside, the station wasn’t as busy as normal for a Saturday morning. I went right to a ticket window and the clerk quickly cleared up the problem and printed our tickets.

Amtrak sent us down to the train platform a few minutes early, and the train, which originated in Harrisburg, Pa., was already there. We boarded and settled in for the hour and 26 minute ride. We left right on time, and even in the snow, we were quickly up to speed.

We remained on-time until about 20 minutes south of New York City, then the lights went out, and the train slowed, then stopped. The conductor reported we had a problem with the engine’s pantograph, the device which collects the electric current from the overhead lines to power the train. For the next 15 minutes, it was stop and start, crawling along at slow speeds.

We were then informed the actual problem was the main electric motor for the train, and that it had nothing to do with the weather. It was about this time we phoned Café Fiorello to tell them we’d probably miss brunch.

After attempting to fix the motor, at about 2 miles from Rahway, NJ, 20 miles south of New York City, our Amtrak engineer, in concert with the conductor made a tough decision, strictly to help their passengers. They decided to abandon the train.

It’s at this point that Amtrak, due to a fast thinking conductor, and the folks at the Amtrak communications center earned tremendous kudos, and sincere thanks from our train load of grateful passengers.

The conductor, a regular on the Keystoner, in concert and in contact with the Amtrak  communications center knew that a New Jersey Transit (NJT) train would be coming up a parallel track past our train soon. They spoke to NJT, and a few minutes later the NJT train pulled along side of us and parked. The 15 minute transfer to the NJT train commenced. It was snowing lightly, very cold, and windy. We all went out on to the track bed, some with big suitcases, others with smaller bags, and climbed up on to the NJT train. The conductors and trainmen from both companies were great. They helped everyone, carried luggage for anyone who needed help, and made sure everyone transferred safely.

At 11:59 am we arrived at New York’s Penn Station, an hour and 10 minutes late. Equipment does break-down at times, notwithstanding an organization’s best efforts. Without Amtrak’s concern for their passengers, as expressed through the conductor and his quick, decisive action, we would have been far, far later, with our day and subscription season ruined.

We took a quick subway ride to Lincoln Center. There was no time for brunch, but were able to grab a sandwich and eat it at the Met, prior to the opera. We bought dessert in the Met’s Belmont Room at intermission.

The ordeal was worth it. The opera was superb. Domingo was glorious, as were each of the principles. When it was over, the applause, the curtain calls, the bravos and bravos went on forever.

Amtrak’s Northeast Regional was on-time taking us home.

Thanks to Amtrak and our conductor, for caring about their passengers and working out a way to solve a tough problem in far less than ideal conditions.

Print Friendly

  • Michael H

    That’s how its done boys and girls – smooth communication, good coordination, and management that can respond to challenges and issues with aplomb.

  • MidMom8949

    oh, Amtrak is the best always. I’m about 60 miles west of Baltimore and I never, ever fly on the East Coast north of NC. When you total the time to fly anywhere on the corridor, it’s actually faster for me to take the train. I go to NY regularly. It would take me an hour to drive to the airport. It takes me an hour to get to Baltimore (with plenty of close by parking at Amtrak). I don’t wait for security, the staff are outrageously pleasant and helpful, the seats are large and comfortable, and I LOVE the quiet car. 2 hours and 35 minutes or so to Penn Station in NY–that’s what it would take me hanging around Dulles airport just to board a plane and be crammed in with no place to put their luggage. Amtrak is way cheaper than flying, too.

    Bravo, Amtrak!

  • Marti

    I would always travel by Amtrak, too, if I could. Unfortunately, in California, the freight trains rule so you end up taking buses between stations and/or waiting on the rails for freight trains to pass. On time? Almost never! Having traveled by train extensively in Europe, I just wish WE could be as civilized. I know it’s not Amtrak’s fault that Union Pacific owns the rails but JEEZ!

  • Alex

    That never wouold have happened if they were in PA and had to rely on SEPTA – the most incompetent transit system I’ve ever experienced.

  • Arizona Road Warrior

    @ MidMom8949: It is cheaper than flying because Amtrak isn’t charging high enough fares to cover their costs; therefore, taxpayers like me who have no access to Amtrak are subsidizing your travel expenditures. When will Amtrak increase their fares so that they can at least break even?

  • Pingback: Train Tickets USA | Train Tickets USA

  • Douglas Stallings

    On the contrary, Arizona Road Warrior, Amtrak service in the Northeast Corridor is both well-run and profitable. It is, perhaps, the only part of Amtrak’s vast network that could stand on its own. Amtrak’s problems in the rest of the country notwithstanding, subsidizing costs is not the problem here. And I wouldn’t really say Amtrak is “cheap”. It’s rather expensive; it’s just that airfares are more expensive.

    In my opinion, the problem with Amtrak is not so much subsidizing fares but having to use scant profits on singular routes to subsidize unneeded and underused service on routes that are not and could not ever be profitable (but are required because a Congressman or Senator demands that a certain route not be dropped).

  • Carrie Charney

    How about some kudos and thanks for the New Jersey Transit crew? Surely they deserve some appreciation! They had to interrupt their schedule to help you guys out. As a fairly regular traveler on both Amtrak (Northeast Corridor route) and New Jersey Transit (Mainline Bergen route +) I can attest that service with a smile has been great on both.

  • Peter

    But, Arizona Road Warrior, aren’t a lot of the expense of flight (controllers, the whole airport infrastructure, aircraft development, etc.) also government-subsidized? And the entire Interstate system that cars and trucks use? And local transit systems too? Why does a service as basic as transportation have to “cover its costs”, any more than do – say – the police, the fire department, and health care?

  • Kairho

    Fortunately, the national subsidy for Amtrak amounts to only about $5 a year per person. Of course a little here, a little there applied. But nonetheless, it’s not all that bad for a national rail system. In fact, it needs to be increased.

  • http://www.tripso.com/author/ned/ Ned Levi

    It turns out that all modes of transportation (not cruise ships as far as I know) are heavily subsidized, road, rail, and air. To single out rail’s subsidy is unfair, in my opinion.

    The Federal Highway Trust Fund, and the Aviation Fund are funded by their respective users, but the amount of funds expended by these funds are not the only expenditures by the federal, state and local governments for roads and aviation. The simple fact is that considerable general tax revenue helps fund all these transportation modes. None of these transportation modes could operate without their sizable subsidies.

    In particular, Amtrak sufferred from having to run specific highly unprofitable routes required of them by the Federal government to get funding. While those requirements were finally lifted, members of the US Congress have made it clear that if Amtrak didn’t keep running many of their unprofitable routes their funding would be substantially cut.

    By the way Carrie, I sent a letter today to NJT thanking them.

  • Frank

    We chose our current season subscription, specifically for Saturday’s opera, Simon Boccanegra, mostly because Plácido Domingo was set to perform the lead role, in this opera, for his first time. In our opinion, he is the world’s greatest living active male opera star. His voice is amazing, and his acting wonderful.
    ==================================================

    Very gracious man. I’ve had Placido Domingo on several flights with his wife, Marta. Enjoyed talking with them. Kind couple.

  • Carrie Charney

    Thank you, Ned. ;-)

  • Eagle Lover

    It is great to read such intelligent dialogue!

Previous post:

Next post: